A new look at the concept and features of economic contradictions

The aim is to study the nature and characteristics of economic contradictions, an attempt to take another look at them and understand the process of interaction of elements of contradictions. Evaluation of opinions of scientists about the essence of the contradictions allowed to cast doubt on the use of economic contradictions based on the logical and philosophical approach. A new understanding of the «contradiction» and the terms «economic contradiction». Their newness is basing on the third law of mechanics of Newton; the allocation of two kinds of counteractions: unexpected or expected but unavoidable in the current environment; designation of properties such counteractions: negative, significant and active; recognition that between the initial and final object is always a subject-object scope of amending the original impulse. It demonstrates a general algorithm for the formation of contradictions. When studying the new position of a number of contradictions in the real economy, they revealed the new features. The article used the abstract-logical method

Keywords: economic controversy, specificity and elements of the contradictions in the economy


  1. Toledo V. The ecological crisis: A second contradiction of capitalism // Capitalism Nature Socialism. Vol. 3, Iss. 3, 1992. pp. 82-84.
  2. Borodin A.I. The nature and content of the main ecological and economic contradictions. Ecology of industrial production [Jekologija promyshlennogo proizvodstva]. 2005. no. 2. pp. 2-6. (in Russian).
  3. Vukovich G.G., Berlin S.I., Skirda A.A. Conflicts of interests transition economy and ways of coordination in terms of ecological imbalance. Successes of modern science [Uspehi sovremennogo estestvoznanija]. 2006. no. 12. pp. 100-102. (in Russian).
  4. Vanags, J., Geipele, I., Mote, G., Jirgena, H. Sustainable development: social dimension and limitation of material needs request. 2012.
  5. Petrushenko N.N. Features environmental management contradictions in economic systems. Herald of Adygeya State University. Episode 5: The Economy [Vestnik Adygejskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija 5: Jekonomika]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 37-44. (in Russian).
  6. Ahmetshina A.R., Ibraeva R.R. Features of ecological and economic contradictions. Kazan Economic Bulletin [Kazanskij jekonomicheskij vestnik]. 2013. no. 2. pp. 96-101. (in Russian).
  7. Manushin D.V. Evaluation of anti-crisis plan of the Russian government in 2015 and the development of measures for its improvement. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2015. no. 3. pp. 45-54. (in Russian).
  8. Manushin D.V. Modern classification of Russian state anti-crisis measures. Journal of Astrakhan State Technical University. Series: Economy [Vestnik Astrahanskogo gosudarstvennogo tehnicheskogo universiteta. Serija: Jekonomika]. 2011. no. 2. pp. 35-42. (in Russian).
  9. Smirnov I.K., Smirnova O.I. Protivorechija sobstvennosti: stanovlenie, razreshenie, razvitie: monografija [Contradictions Ownership: Formation, permit the development of: a monograph]. SPb .: Publishing house of the St. Petersburg State University, 2004. 160 p.
  10. Smirnov I.K. Formal logic and dialectical contradictions. Problems of Modern Economics [Problemy sovremennoj jekonomiki]. 2012. no. 4. pp. 29-33. (in Russian).
  11. Zgonnik L.V. The research methodology economic contradictions. Rusnauka [Rusnauka]. 2006. (in Russian). Available at: http://www.rusnauka.com/NPM_2006/Economics/14_zgonnik.doc.htm (accessed 12.05.2016).
  12. Koroljuk E.V. Economic contradictions as the categorical reflection of domain-systemic activity of economic entities // Institute of Economics and Law Ivan Kushnir: International Economic Forum [Institut jekonomiki i prava Ivana Kushnira: mezhdunarodnyj jekonomicheskij forum]. 2011. (in Russian). Available at: http://www.be5.biz/ekonomika1/r2011/1471.htm(accessed 12.05.2016).
  13. Rzhevskaja A.P. Contradictions manifestation of property relations in the economic institutions. Proceedings of the Free Economic Society of Russia [Nauchnye trudy Vol'nogo jekonomicheskogo obshhestva Rossii]. 2012. Vol. 163. pp. 521-530. (in Russian).
  14. Haustov A.V. Features of the contradictions in the social and labor sphere of the region and technology solutions. Terra Economicus [Terra Economicus]. 2011. Vol. 9. no. 3-3. pp. 138-142. (in Russian).
  15. Kuc V.I. The effectiveness of the individual forms of realization of the competitiveness of high-tech industrial sectors. Economic science [Jekonomicheskie nauki]. 2011. no. 84. pp. 20-24. (in Russian).
  16. Svitich A.A. Specificity of the contradictions of economic interests in the conditions of globalization. National interests: priorities and security [Nacional'nye interesy: prioritety i bezopasnost']. 2013. no. 11. pp. 45-53. (in Russian).
  17. Sliva S.V. Features of the contradictions of the modern socio-economic development. Of the Caspian region: politics, economy, culture [Kaspijskij region: politika, jekonomika, kul'tura]. 2013. no. 4. pp. 168-175. (in Russian).
  18. Ivanenko A.A. The specifics of the analysis of social contradictions. Philosophy of Law [Filosofija prava]. 2008. no. 3. pp. 117-119. (in Russian).
  19. Kuz'menkova O.V. Personal resources constructive resolution of psychological contradictions. Problems of modern science and practice. University. IN AND. Vernadsky [Voprosy sovremennoj nauki i praktiki. Universitet im. V.I. Vernadskogo]. 2009. no. 12. pp. 39-46. (in Russian).
  20. Bochkov V.E. Open and distance education system: the problems of formation for the industry and prospects of its development as an object of industry of the national economy. Modern high technologies [Sovremennye naukoemkie tehnologii]. 2004. no. 2. pp. 125-132. (in Russian).
  21. Pshikova A.M. The contradictions of the economic mechanism of the economy. Management of economic systems: electronic scientific journal [Upravlenie jekonomicheskimi sistemami: jelektronnyj nauchnyj zhurnal]. 2006. no. 7. pp. 2-5. (in Russian). Available at: http://uecs.ru/teoriya-upravleniya/item/57-2011-03-19-09-32-10 (accessed 28.04.2016).
  22. Batajkin P.A. Transformation of contradictions between the factors of consumer demand in the modern economy. Journal of economics, law and sociology [Vestnik jekonomiki, prava i sociologii]. 2010. no. 3. pp. 12-14. (in Russian).
  23. Mannakov T.V. The contradictions of formal and informal institutions of the Russian economy small business. Intelligence. Innovation. Investments [Intellekt. Innovacii. Investicii]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 48-52. (in Russian).
  24. Maksimova T.P. The forms of managing in agrarian sector of the Na-tional economy: contradictions of de jure and de facto. Problems of Economics and Law [Voprosy jekonomiki i prava]. 2013. no. 66. pp. 129-134. (in Russian).
  25. Ivanenko A.A. Features of the research as a process of contradictions: from Aristotle to Leibniz. Actual problems of the humanities and natural sciences [Aktual'nye problemy gumanitarnyh i estestvennyh nauk]. 2011. no. 1. pp. 106-110. (in Russian).
  26. Egger E., Hanappi G. Modelling creative contradictions for organizational change // System Sciences, 1995. Proceedings of the Twenty-Eighth Hawaii International Conference on. IEEE, 1995. Vol. 4. pp. 871-880.
  27. Panachev V.Ju. The contradictions in the system of economic relations as a threat to the financial security of the region. Actual problems of economic science [Aktual'nye voprosy jekonomicheskih nauk]. 2008. no. 1. pp. 243-247. (in Russian).
  28. Morozova N.I. The basic economic contradiction today, the motion-zhenie basic economic contradictions - the basis for the strategy of reforming the Russian economy. Russian Entrepreneurship [Rossijskoe predprinimatel'stvo]. 2009. no. 8-1. pp. 28-32. (in Russian).
  29. Kochkurova E.V. On the concept of structural change in the modern economy, their causes and contradictions. Bulletin of the International Institute of Management LINK [Vestnik Mezhdunarodnogo instituta menedzhmenta LINK]. 2010. no. 26. pp. 65-75. (in Russian).
  30. Karpuhina N.I., Shibanova-Roenko E.A. The contradictions between the functioning and development of the socio-economic system as a genetic basis crises. Successes of modern science [Uspehi sovremennogo estestvoznanija]. 2012. no. 4. pp. 105-107. (in Russian).
  31. Muratov A.S., Muratova L.N. "The world is woven of contradictions ..." a basis for modernization of economic relations. Creative Economy [Kreativnaja jekonomika]. 2010. no. 9. pp. 3-10. (in Russian).
  32. Vukovich G.G., Gorlanova A.Je. Prevention and resolution of conflicts of the labor market: a regional perspective. Society: sociology, psychology, pedagogy [Obshhestvo: sociologija, psihologija, pedagogika]. 2012. no. 1. pp. 37-41. (in Russian).
  33. Ugnich E.A. The economic nature of conflict and the development of venture capital in the Russian economy. Research and development. Economy [Nauchnye issledovanija i razrabotki. Jekonomika]. 2013. T. 1. no. 2. pp. 31-39. (in Russian).
  34. Ahmedzjanova F.K., Galanceva I.V. Contradictions manufacturing and financial sectors of the economy to generate ways to increase the efficiency of the modern economy. Journal of Kazan State Technological University [Vestnik Kazanskogo tehnologicheskogo universiteta]. 2013. T. 16. no. 2. pp. 218-221. (in Russian).
  35. Ryzhikova N.P., Kovalenko V.N. Contradictions of formation of competitiveness of the economy of the Far East. Bulletin of scientific society of students, graduate students and young scientists [Vestnik nauchnogo obshhestva studentov, aspirantov i molodyh uchenyh]. 2014. no. 3. pp. 142-147. (in Russian).
  36. Kulikov B.B. The contradictions of the economic system of socialism as the source of its development. Questions of economy [Voprosy jekonomiki]. 1986. no. 1. (in Russian).
  37. Naumenko N. To a question about the contradictions of economic laws. Economics [Jekonomicheskie nauki]. 1988. no. 11. (in Russian).
  38. Zaloznaja G.M. The contradictions of the national-state economic systems. Bulletin of the Orenburg State University [Vestnik Orenburgskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta]. 2004. no. 9. pp. 83-89. (in Russian).
  39. Meshherjakov D.A. Contradictions between the interests of businesses and their endorsement. In: Transformation of economic interests in modern Russia. Collection of scientific papers [V sbornike: Transformacija jekonomicheskih interesov v sovremennoj Rossii. Sbornik nauchnyh trudov]. 2006. pp. 116-124. (in Russian).
  40. Russkova E.G. The contradictions of the infrastructure of the market economy and the mechanism of their solution. Herald of Volgograd State University. Series 3: The Economy. Ecology [Vestnik Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija 3: Jekonomika. Jekologija]. 2007. no. 11. pp. 29-33. (in Russian).
  41. Batishhev D.G. The contradictions in the system of economic interests of subjects of market relations. Terra Economicus [Terra Economicus]. 2009. T. 7. no. 4-2. pp. 20-22. (in Russian).
  42. Garifova L.F. The contradictions of the economic interests of companies in the Internet environment. Actual problems of economic science [Aktual'nye voprosy jekonomicheskih nauk]. 2010. no. 13. pp. 382-385. (in Russian).
  43. Starodubceva N.A. Types and forms of settlement of economic contradictions. International journal of experimental education [Mezhdunarodnyj zhurnal jeksperimental'nogo obrazovanija]. 2011. no. 8. pp. 287-289. (in Russian).
  44. Volkova G.G. The contradictions of the development of the nonprofit sector of eco-nomic: theoretical and methodological aspects. Proceedings of the University of Saratov. New episode. Series: Economy. Control. Right [Izvestija Saratovskogo universiteta. Novaja serija. Serija: Jekonomika. Upravlenie. Pravo]. 2011. T. 11. no. 1. pp. 20-23. (in Russian).
  45. Kul'kov V.M. The logic of economic contradictions (the 200th anniversary of the publication of the "Science of Logic" Hegel). Philosophy of Economy [Filosofija hozjajstva]. 2012. no. 6. pp. 103-117. (in Russian).
  46. Bai G., Henesey L. Coping with System Sustainability: A Sociocybernetics Model for Social‐Economic System Architecture // Systems Research and Behavioral Science. 2012. Vol. 29. no. 3. pp. 263-273.
  47. Zueva O.A. The contradictions of the real sector and their impact on the system of economic contradictions. Bulletin of St. Petersburg State University of Economics [Известия Санкт-Петербургского государственного экономического университета]. 2014. no. 6. pp. 14-21. (in Russian).
  48. Korolyuk E.V. Use of Dialectic Method in Economic Studies // World Applied Sciences Journal. 2014. T. 30 no. 6. pp. 747-750.
  49. Ljamkin I.I. The contradiction of the innovation process in the field of trade. In: The trajectories of reforming of the Russian economy. Proceedings of the International Economic Symposium on the 50th anniversary of the Faculty of Economics of TSU. The Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, Tomsk State University [V sbornike: Traektorii reformirovanija rossijskoj jekonomiki. Materialy Mezhdunarodnogo jekonomicheskogo simpoziuma, posvjashhennogo 50-letiju jekonomicheskogo fakul'teta TGU. Ministerstvo obrazovanija i nauki rossijskoj federacii, Tomskij gosudarstvennyj universitet]. 2014. pp. 326-334. (in Russian).
  50. Gerasimov V.M., Grigorjan F.R. Protivorechija finansovogo vzaimodejstvija bankovskogo i real'nogo sektorov jekonomiki sovremennoj Rossii: monografija [The contradictions of financial cooperation of the banking and real sectors of the modern economy of Russia: a monograph]. M.: Publishing and Trading Corporation "Dashkov and K °», 2014. 191 p.
  51. Frolov D.P., Lavrent'eva A.V. Institutional contradictions as the source of dysfunctions, anomalies and pathologies of economic institutions. In: Topical issues of economics, management and finance in modern conditions. Collection of scientific papers on the results of the international scientific-practical conference [V sbornike: Aktual'nye voprosy jekonomiki, menedzhmenta i finansov v sovremennyh uslovijah. Sbornik nauchnyh trudov po itogam mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii]. 2015. pp. 14-15. (in Russian).
  52. Golub L.A. The objectives of the subjects of economic processes. basic contradictions. In: Dominating Principles and factors of formation of territories of advancing social and economic development. Collection of articles on materials of the international scientific-practical conference correspondence [V sbornike: Aktual'nye voprosy jekonomiki, menedzhmenta i finansov v sovremennyh uslovijah. Sbornik nauchnyh trudov po itogam mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii]. 2015. pp. 23-29. (in Russian).
  53. Petrushenko M.M., Voroshylo L.S. Environmental-economic conflict: conceptual complexity and management issues [Online] // Economic Processes Management: International Scientific E-Journal. 2015. no. 3.
  54. Vladimirskij E.A., Pavlova I.P. Sistema socialisticheskih proizvodstvennyh otnoshenij. Metodologija analiza, struktura, dvizhushhie sily razvitija [The system of socialist production relations. The methodology of the analysis, the structure, the driving force for development]. Leningrad: Leningrad University Publishing, 1986, 208 p.
  55. Glushhenko E.N., Drozdovskaja L.P., Rozhkov Ju.V. Finansovoe posrednichestvo kommercheskih bankov: monografija [Financial intermediation of commercial banks: a monograph]. Khabarovsk: RIC KSAEL, 2011. 240 p.
  56. Gallagher B. James O'Conner, The Fiscal Crisis of the State // CTheory. – 1979. Т. 3. no. 2. pp. 196-198.
  57. Popkova E.G., Tinyakova V.I. Dialectical methodology of analysis of economic growth // World Applied Sciences Journal. 2013. Т. 24. no. 4. pp. 467-475.
  58. Chernysh M.F. The cultural contradictions of the Russian economy. Russia reformed [Rossija reformirujushhajasja]. 2003. no. 3. pp. 158-175. (in Russian).
  59. Lisicyna Ja. The post-crisis world: in search of points of growth. Effective crisis management [Jeffektivnoe antikrizisnoe upravlenie]. 2014. no. 1. pp. 22-29. (in Russian).
  60. Sobieska-Karpińska J., Hernes M. Using consensus methods in knowledge conflicts resolving in supply chain management support systems // Information Systems in Management. 2012. Vol. 1. no. 2. pp. 160-167.
  61. Manushin D.V. Administrative barriers in the Russian economy as the conditions conducive to the existence of corruption, and measures to address them. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2014. no. 4. pp. 52-60. (in Russian).
  62. Manushin D.V. Crisis Management Russian heavy ma-engineering industry: the institutional approach. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 131-137. (in Russian).
  63. Manushin D.V. Crisis governance-Russia's economy: the institutional approach. Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2014. no. 3. pp. 23-34. (in Russian).
  64. Gafurova G.T. Institutional aspects of increase of efficiency of state regulation of the securities market. Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2010. no. 22. pp. 52-59. (in Russian).
  65. Jakupov Z.S. Influence of state institutions for the organization of tax control. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2014. no. 3. pp. 106-112. (in Russian).
  66. Jakupov Z.S. On the role of institutions, taxation and tax control in the implementation of the sustainable development strategy of modern Russia. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2015. no. 1. pp. 125-133. (in Russian).
  67. Sharipov S.A., Harisov G.A., Kolpakov P.A. Formation of the institutional environment of innovative development of agrarian and industrial complex. Economics of Agriculture of Russia [Jekonomika sel'skogo hozjajstva Rossii]. 2013. no. 6. pp. 059-070. (in Russian).
  68. Sergeev D.A. Asymmetric information in the market of public procurement and some direction to overcome. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2011. no. 2. pp. 35-38. (in Russian).
  69. Jakushkin N.M., Sharipov S.A., Kolpakov P.A., Harisov G.A., Safiullin R.H. Factors institutional environment and innovation as a tool for improving the competitiveness of agriculture. AIC: Economics & Management [APK: Jekonomika, upravlenie]. 2015. no. 4. pp. 35-39. (in Russian).
  70. Grigor'ev R.A., Kramin M.V., Kramin T.V., Timirjasova A.V. Income distribution inequality and economic growth in the regions of Russia in the post-crisis period. The economy of the region [Jekonomika regiona]. 2015. no. 3. pp. 102-113. (in Russian).
  71. Grigor'ev R.A., Klimanova A.R., Kramin M.V., Kramin T.V. Social capital as a factor in increasing the competitiveness of economic systems. Vector Science Togliatti State University. Series: Economics and Management [Vektor nauki Tol'jattinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Jekonomika i upravlenie]. 2015. no. 4. pp. 29-34. (in Russian).
  72. Buranova E.A. Clarification of the concept of "institutional crisis management now". Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2015. no. 32. pp. 11-25. (in Russian).
  73. Manushin D.V. Clarification of the concept of "macro-economic system". The economic analysis: theory and practice [Jekonomicheskij analiz: teorija i praktika]. 2013. no. 39. pp. 15-25. (in Russian).
  74. Manushin D.V. Clarification of the concept of "macro-economic crisis". Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2014. no. 25. pp. 39-55. (in Russian).
  75. Marks K. Kapital [Capital]: 4 tons Vol.1, 1867; Vol.2, 1873.; Vol.3, 1885.; Volume 4, 1890.; 580. Access: http://anticapitalist.ru/books/kapital.pdf (accessed 28.04.2016).
  76. Willmott H. Studying managerial work: a critique and a proposal [1] //Journal of management studies. 1987. Т. 24. no. 3. pp. 249-270.
  77. Smirnov V.L. Paradoxical fundamental ideas of modern economics, management, finance (the crisis, the conditions of contradiction, methodology). Bulletin of economic security [Vestnik jekonomicheskoj bezopasnosti]. 2010. no. 3. pp. 36-49. (in Russian).
  78. Valishvili M.A. The optimization of the economic effectiveness, efficiency and social justice as a way to overcome the antagonistic contradiction between capital and labor. Russian Economic Internet-Journal [Rossijskij jekonomicheskij internet-zhurnal]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 9. (in Russian). Available at: http://www.e-rej.ru/upload/iblock/cc8/cc8a65aa8e448795b27e18e79a592c2b.pdf (accessed 28.04.2016).
  79. Teplov G.V. Economic laws and contradictions of the system economic interests. Vestnik Samara Municipal Institute-ment councils [Vestnik Samarskogo municipal'nogo instituta upravlenija]. 2014. no. 1. pp. 120-128. (in Russian).
  80. Barhatov V.I. Nature and contradictions success of small and medium business in the modern economy. Herald of Chelyabinsk State University [Vestnik Cheljabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta]. 2014. no. 21. pp. 8-14. (in Russian).
  81. Manushin D.V. A new look at the concept of "crisis". The economic analysis: theory and practice [Jekonomicheskij analiz: teorija i praktika]. 2013. no. 15. pp. 17-24. (in Russian).
  82. Manushin D.V. Modern classification of macroeconomic crises. Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2013. no. 2. pp. 35-46. (in Russian).
  83. Manushin D.V. Overview, synthesis and evaluation of the theory of economic cycles and crises. Isolation and comparison of new theories: political and economic conditional cycle and endless crisis. Finances and Credit [Finansy i kredit]. 2016. no. 2. pp. 9-26. (in Russian).
  84. Saurenko T.N. The contradictions in the system of economic interests. Terra Economicus [Terra Economicus]. 2006. no. 1. pp. 164-168. (in Russian).
  85. Vladimirskij E.A. The world economy at the turn of the century: the contradictions, trends. Economic Revival of Russia [Jekonomicheskoe vozrozhdenie Rossii]. 2006. no. 2. pp. 27-31. (in Russian).
  86. Ljubeckij V.V. The Russian economy at the beginning of the XXI century: achievements and contradictions. Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 18: Sociology and Political Science [Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Serija 18: Sociologija i politologija]. 2009. T. 18. no. 3. pp. 36-40. (in Russian).
  87. Morozova E.V. Problems and contradictions of Russian state corporations in modern economy. Transport business in Russia [Transportnoe delo Rossii]. 2010. no. 3. pp. 102-105. (in Russian).
  88. Fjodorov M.N. Modern contradictions in the development of a competitive economy in Russia. Proceedings of the Center for Advanced Economic Studies [Nauchnye trudy Centra perspektivnyh jekonomicheskih issledovanij]. 2010. no. 3. pp. 125-131. (in Russian).
  89. Babaev B.D., Borovkova N.V., Nikolaeva E.E., Nikolaev A.D., Novikov A.I., Andrekus E.A. The economy of depressive region: contradictions reserves revival projects. Herald of Ivanovo State University. Series: Economy [Vestnik Ivanovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Jekonomika]. 2013. no. 1. pp. 6-21. (in Russian).
  90. Chabanjuk O.V. Problems and contradictions of modern innovative economy in Russia. Achievements of university research [Dostizhenija vuzovskoj nauki]. 2013. no. 2. pp. 121-126. (in Russian).
  91. Postaljuk M.P., Postaljuk T.M., Sabirov M.R.Trends and contradictions of venture financing of innovative systems in the Russian economy. Herald TISBI [Vestnik TISBI]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 55-71. (in Russian).
  92. Mikul'skij K.I. Russia's economy and its social system contradictions. the Society and economy [Obshhestvo i jekonomika]. 2014. no. 12. pp. 5-10. (in Russian).
  93. Porezanova E.V. Risks and modernization of the contradictions in the modern economy of Russia. Proceedings of the University of Saratov. New episode. Series: Economy. Control. Right [Izvestija Saratovskogo universiteta. Novaja serija. Serija: Jekonomika. Upravlenie. Pravo]. 2014. T. 14. no. 1-2. pp. 127-132. (in Russian).
  94. Konovalova O.N., Surzhikova T.B. Economic Integration: contradictions and prospects of development in the system of the modern world economy. Innovative economy and society [Innovacionnaja jekonomika i obshhestvo]. 2014. no. 3. pp. 40-45. (in Russian).
  95. Juneva E.A. The contradictions of the institutional transformation of the informal sector of the economy. Actual problems of Economics and Management [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i menedzhmenta]. 2014. no. 4. pp. 79-85. (in Russian).
  96. State regulation of the economy: the laws and contradictions: a collective monograph. Rostov-on-Don, 2014. 204 р. (in Russian).
  97. Kadomceva S.V., Manahova I.V. Social conflicts as a factor of instability in the information economy. Information security of regions [Informacionnaja bezopasnost' regionov]. 2015. no. 4. pp. 60-64. (in Russian).
  98. Bubnov A.V. Contradictions of cluster development of the Russian economy. Transport business in Russia [Transportnoe delo Rossii]. 2015. no. 6. pp. 7-9. (in Russian).
  99. Varlamova T.P. The interaction of economic interests and their contradictions in the conditions of modern Russian economy. Volga trade and economic journal [Povolzhskij torgovo-jekonomicheskij zhurnal]. 2011. no. 1. pp. 53-58. (in Russian).
  100. Kopylova Ju.G. The essence, the purpose and the basic contradictions of Russian policy with regard to the underground economy. Modern problems of science and education [Sovremennye problemy nauki i obrazovanija]. 2014. no. 2. pp. 426. (in Russian).
  101. Jakupov Z.S. Control function of the tax in relation to its other functions. Actual problems of Economics and Law [Aktual'nye problemy jekonomiki i prava]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 171-175. (in Russian).
  102. Jakupov Z.S. Conceptual bases of formation of an effective system of fiscal controls. Horizons economy [Gorizonty jekonomiki]. 2013. no. 3. pp. 60-64.
  103. Notfullina G.N., Gafurova G.T. Performance issues Tatarstan budget revenues and solutions. Journal of Astrakhan State Technical University. Series: Economy [Vestnik Astrahanskogo gosudarstvennogo tehnicheskogo universiteta. Serija: Jekonomika]. 2013. no. 2. pp. 214-220. (in Russian).
  104. Gil'manov Je.M. Questions of criminal liability for violation of budgetary discipline. Vector Science Togliatti State University. Series: jurisprudence [Vektor nauki Tol'jattinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: juridicheskie nauki]. 2011. no. 1. pp. 46-48. (in Russian).
  105. Homenko V.V., Salimov L.N. Recent trends of international regulation of innovation activity. Integral [Integral]. 2010. no. 2. pp. 72-74. (in Russian).