The lapses of the Federal law № 172-FZ «On strategic planning in the Russian Fede ration»

Eight lapses of regulation of strategic planning are shown by this law. The 1st — planning as voluntary, unilateral activity of the power. the 2nd — subjects of economic activity do not participate in strategic planning of economic development. the 3rd — follows from the name of the law that it regulates any strategic planning in the Russian Federation, but does not provide that which is carried out by citizens and legal entities, having deprived of legal value such planning. the 4th — is absent regulation of procedures and actions of participants of process of strategic planning. 5es — instead of positive legal regulation the law makes nominative formulation, and definitions of the law do not contain intrinsic signs of the defined concepts. the 6th — under the law strategy, does not take interests and actions of the legal subjects competing in the international and domestic markets into consideration. 7th — the law assumes one-alternativeness of the forecasts and strategy relying on uncontested goal-setting which it is groundless mixes up with a problem of ensuring national security of the Russian Federation. the 8th — the law, contrary to modern foreign and Soviet experience, does not create legal institute of special competence in strategic planning, the body of the state executing it

Keywords: strategy, strategic planning, participants of strategic planning, consensus of levels of the public power at strategic planning, federal economic service of strategic planning of the Russian Federation, Federal вank of the planned credits and investments of the Russian Federation


  1. 1.N. M. Kazantsev § 4 Administrative legislation in the sphere of regulation and management of economy. / In the head the Concept of development of the administrative legislation. Yu.A. Tikhomirov, A.F. Nozdrachyov, N.M. Kazantsev, L.K. Tereshchenko, N.A. Ignatyuk, V.N. Petukhov, E.I. Spector, A.V. Kalmykova//In prince: Concepts of development of the Russian legislation / Under the editorship of T.Ya. Habriyeva, Yu.A. Tikhomirov, Yu.P. Orlovsky. M, JSC Gorodets Publishing House, 2004, S. 461-488.
  2.  2 N. M. Kazantsev § 4 Administrative legislation in the sphere of regulation and management of economy. page 485.
  3. Schlesinger Jr. A.M. Cycles of the American history. M, Progress, 1992. - 688 pages - Page 316.Schlesinger Jr. A.M. Cycles of the American history. Page 318.
  4. This plan not in the State planning commission of the USSR (the State Planning Committee of the USSR), and owing to exclusive requirements to computing capacities in one of scientific and production associations of the Ministry of the radio industry of the USSR paid off.
  5. Leontyev V.V. Economic essays. Theories, researches, facts and policy. The lane with English M., Politizdat, 1990.
  6. David French British Economic and Strategic Planning: I905-1915. Routledge, 5 noyab. 2013 of First Published in 2005. Routledge is an imprint of Taylor & Francis, an informa company. - 208p.
  7. See: N. M. Kazantsev. Gaps of the federal law on strategic planning. In prince: Problems of science of Administrative Law: materials of the scientific conference "Lazarevsky Readings" (on November 20-21, 2014). M, 2015. Page 136-142.
  8. Liddel Gart. Strategy of indirect actions. M, 2014.
  9. This exact name of the Nobel Prize in the field of economy which was founded by Bank of Sweden in the memory of A. Nobel.
  10. See: Tyrol Zh. Markets and market power: the theory of the organization of the industry / lane with English SPb.1996.
  11. Schelling T. Strategy of the conflict/T. Schelling; the lane from English T. Danilova under the editorship of Yu. Kuzknektsov, K. Sonin. M.: 2007. Page 155, 12. URL.: wiki/Thomas_Schelling,
  12. Association of the United Nations - Great Britain (UNA-UK) is the leading independent director of policy issues concerning the United Nations in Great Britain and the wide member organization in scales of all Great Britain.
  16. The Planning Process in the US and Germany: A Comparative Analysis. Stephan Schmidt_ & Ralph Buehler Department of City and Regional Planning, Cornell University,
  17. Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, Rutgers University.//International Planning Studies Vol. 12, No. 1, 55–75, February 2007.
  18. Kazantsev N.M. Method of transactional strategic planning./В prince: Economical and legal institutes of regulation of regional development: monograph / N.M. Kazantsev, E.M. Bukhvald, A.R. Bakhtizin, etc.; under the editorship of N.M. Kazantsev. M, 2013. Page 138-183.